Why I Stopped Using Adobe Products

There are alternatives to Photoshop and Lightroom

I have had some technical difficulties lately. It started when my Mac decided to start making awful noises whenever I booted it up. Granted, I have had that computer for about a decade so I guess I can’t be to disappointed. It was time for a new computer and I started taking inventory of my software tools wondering if I needed to upgrade them while I was at it. Shortly after, Adobe announced that they changed their terms of use so they can basically take any imagery, photograph or otherwise, from their products to train their A.I. model. That was my tipping point… It was time to dump Adobe.

I have been using Photoshop since version 2.0 and have loved using it. It really is a great tool and so is Lightroom. They are the premier tools for photo editing, design, illustration etc. I have become very familiar with them over the years. However, it seems that Adobe wants to bit the hand that feeds it. Hard.

To leverage the very tools that creatives use against them seems very short sighted to me. I could be wrong. I get it, the A.I. tools can be a real boost to creativity and take ideas further, faster and better. I don’t have a problem with that. It’s the idea that Adobe thinks they can just steal previous customers work to make a tool that will impact the opportunities of other creatives.

I have decided not to participate in Adobe taking advantage of the industry it is supposed to empower.

Now, don’t think I am not aware of all the other A.I. models using images from all corners of the internet, I am. I get it, A.I. can be a really great tool but not at my expense (if I can help it).

Tybee Beach Pier and Pavilion taken with Nikon F4, Nikkor 35-135mm, Foma 400 film. Processed in GIMP 2.0 instead of Adobe Photoshop.
Tybee Beach Pier and Pavilion, Tybee Island Georgia.

What am I going to use now?

I decided to go for the most affordable (i.e. FREE) solutions first, figuring that if they didn’t meet my needs I wasn’t out of any cash and it could only get better with other tools if these didn’t work out. Right now I am experimenting with GIMP and Darktable for my digital image editing.

I went with these two because there is an extensive developer and user community behind them. They may not get as regular updates as commercial software but they are stable and get updates on a consistent basis. Not to mention their price tag.

What about GIMP?

GIMP is actually pretty good. The above image was an old scan that I had in my archive and decided to run it through GIMP to see if I could take it where I wanted. Overall, I was able to quickly get where I wanted the final image to be. Photoshop users should be able to transition well to GIMP. It does lack two features (and has one bug) that, if weren’t missing, would make it a perfect replacement for me. Your mileage may vary. Remember, I started using Photoshop back in the day when there wasn’t layers…

A good clone healing tool

The clone healing tool in GIMP is a little cumbersome to use. Not as easy as Photoshop. GIMP makes you select a source area of the image and then you use the clone tool to spot dust or whatever you need. It’ not content aware like PS tools. Not perfect but workable.

Adjustment Layers

This is kind of a big one for me. I used adjustment layers in PS all the time. A great way to do none destructive editing on my original image. Without it in GIMP I am required to create copies of layers before I make an adjustment. Just in case I need to go back a step. Not a great workflow. There is a plan for this feature to be in a future release of GIMP but who knows how long it will take. So I will solder on for now with multiple layers, for a while anyway.

Darktable direct export to GIMP 2.0 doesn’t work (known bug)

After doing general edits in Darktable users used to be able to export directly into GIMP. However, since GIMP 2.0 that export from Darktable doesn’t work anymore. It works with older versions of GIMP but not 2.0. That’s a bummer because if you want to go from Darktable to GIMP you need to export a new file to open into GIMP. I am still learning Darktable so I don’t really know how much this will impact my workflow but I expect it could be annoying. A fix is supposed to be in the works but again who knows how long it will be before it’s released.

How about Darktable?

If someone told you Darktable is like Lighroom, don’t believe them. Both are capable and get you there fast but Darktable works differently than Lightroom in many ways. The workflow in Darktable is close enough to Lightroom that I got confused more often than not. I have to unlearn some things in order to use Darktable proficiently. I am by no means an expert or even very proficient in either one so I don’t have much to say about Darktable beyond this. It is powerful, fast and works really well. It’s just a different process. More to come on that one.


Get the latest from me in your inbox

If you like the content I post here on the blog then maybe you will be interested in my email newsletter. I send them out with other news, thoughts and tips on photography as well special print offers. Add your email in the form below. You can unsubscribe anytime, you won’t hurt my feelings.

Black and White Photography Exhibition at A Smith Gallery

I am excited to share with you that one of my black and white photographs has been accepted into the Black and White Exhibition at the A Smith Gallery in Johnson City, TX. As well as being selected for the “27”, a final cut of selected photographs to be published in a limited edition book. You can watch the gallery chat video on the gallery site here. When the book is available you can purchase it or purchase the whole exhibition catalog to see all the photographs.

Watch the Gallery Talk about all the images selected for the exhibition

A big thanks to Amanda Smith and Kevin Tully for supporting photographers and their work. They work very hard at what they do and it shows. Also, a big thanks to the exhibition juror Ann Jastrab of the Center for Photographic Art in Carmel, CA for selecting my “On the Hunt” photo to be in the show.

What are Print Editions?

If you have been looking into purchasing a fine art photograph you may have noticed that many times a photographer will label the prints as limited edition or open edition or even non edition prints. What does all that mean? What does it have to do with the photograph you may be purchasing and how does it affect you? Let’s take a look.

Unlike other forms of visual art, photography (and sculpture in some cases) can make many copies or versions of an original. Paintings are different. Sure, you can make a copy of a painting and sell posters, limited edition prints etc. but you can hang the original on the wall and there is only one original. With a fine art photograph the final product isn’t a negative or a digital file, it’s the print. However, the print is where the last portion of the creative process is done by the artist with photography. This makes photographic prints inherently reproducible making it impossible to have an “original”.

With that said, fine art photographs are made, not taken. Much more than a press of the shutter button goes into the creation of a final photographic print.

Limited Edition

A limited edition simply means that a photographer has decided they will only produce a set number of prints for a particular image. It is a promise to the collectors, that the photographer will only produce a limited number of prints. For example, a photographer may decide to only produce 10 prints of the London Bridge. Each print is numbered 1-10 out of 10 i.e., 1/10, 2/10. Therefore, it is called a limited edition.

If a photographer limits their prints it puts some responsibility on the them to maintain provenance of the edition. This means the photographer needs to keep records of all prints made and sold. This should include who the original purchaser is, what number print of the edition it was, and any other details. By doing this the photographer can prove the value of any print that is purchased by a collector. Of course with any print an artist should provide a Certificate of Authenticity (COA). More on that later in this post.

A Time and Place. Limited Edition Silver Gelatin Print, 1 of 10, signed by the artist. Exhibited 2015, Littleton Museum, Littleton CO.

There are some pro’s and con’s to this approach. The big upsides to collecting limited editions is that there is only so many of these objects created. This automatically creates value if the print is popular. This also depends on the number of prints in an edition. If a photographer prints 200 in an edition, then, in my opinion it’s not that scarce and the chances of most photographers selling out an edition of 200 is rare. However, if a photographer prints 20 in an edition, then the value of each print should be higher. If you are a collector and can get in early on a limited edition the value of the photograph has a likelihood of continuing to hold it’s value. Not to mention the uniqueness of owning such a limited supply of the print.

Singed and Numbered

On the downside, there is no guarantee that the print will hold it’s value. Also, for the photographer, this really limits their ability to create more prints if the photograph becomes popular, painting them into a corner. Many times a photographer will raise the price of a print as the edition sells. This makes sense because when a print is popular, the edition has a good chance of selling out. If the photographer has limited availability to sell the print they can gauge value by how well it sells, maximizing their potential profit from the sales.

Open Editions

When you buy an open edition print you should be getting the same quality, and attention given to the print as a limited edition, BUT there is no limit on the amount of prints the photographer is going to make. With open editions, certificate of authenticity, artist signature, purchase price and number of print should all be provided with the print. This still lends provenance to the print just like a limited edition except that there is no end to the print run. It could be a very popular photograph and be printed 800 times or, not so popular, and printed only 5 times.
I feel that open edition prints are a good middle ground for both the photographer and the collector to get into collecting photographic fine art prints. It let’s an early or mid career photographer to find out what work is most sought after and collectors to get in on a print when they have the budget to purchase.

If a mid career photographer sees success and starts to be heavily collected or represented by a gallery, the photographer can stop producing open editions and move to limited editions. If a photographer keeps good records of who has purchased open edition prints he or she can contact all the collectors notifying them that the open edition has been closed.

Non Editions

This is simply a print that is sold without any provenance or documentation. Many times without an artist signature. To a collector these are not as desirable. Sure, it may be a fantastic photograph, and if you love it buy it! If it brings you joy and happiness when you look at it that is the most important, but it probably won’t be something collectable. If you enjoy photographs and don’t really care what their value will be, but you want it hanging on your wall, then non edition prints are a great way to go for adding some interest to your home or office. Don’t let it stop you from buying one.

Certificate of Authenticity

When purchasing any time of art a collector should expect to get a certificate of authenticity (COA). This is a detailed account of the origin of the artwork. It should state the artists name, title of the work, dimensions date the print was issued, what number in the edition, signature, as well as other pertinent details.

The COA is a very important part of purchasing a piece of art. Without it, the artworks value is much less.

What About Me?

For now, I provide my collectors with Open Edition black and white fine art prints. I am not represented by a gallery at this time, so I don’t really see the need to put limits on my print numbers. I feel that this is the most flexible approach for me as a photographer, and still provides a high level of value to any collector who purchase prints from me. If things change in the future I may close an open edition but for now they are open.

If you want to purchase a print from me please inquire. Soon, I will have online purchasing at my website.

Hopefully this was some helpful information for you as you begin your photographic collecting. As Always, if you want to be kept in the loop, sign up for my email list. I send info on new prints, exhibitions and general happenings so you can keep tabs on the latest.

Black and white is the first step to abstraction